Protecting Veteran Choice: Examining VA’s Community Care Program - Senate Hearing (01/28/2025)
Sources
Navigating the Maze: Challenges and Opportunities in VA Community Care
The VA Community Care Program is intended to offer veterans more options for healthcare, providing access to community providers when the VA cannot offer timely or accessible services. This program is a vital resource, especially for veterans in rural areas or those who prefer care outside of the VA system. Despite its potential, many veterans encounter significant hurdles when trying to access community care. Let's take a closer look at the challenges and opportunities within this crucial program.
The Promise of Community Care
The Community Care Program has shown some success. It has broadened access to care, allowing veterans to seek services from community providers when the VA’s services are not readily available. Many veterans find this option appealing because of convenience, time considerations, or a lack of trust in the VA system. Additionally, the program has the potential to foster strong partnerships between VA facilities and community providers. Telehealth has also emerged as a useful tool, particularly in bridging service gaps in underserved areas.
Challenges Veterans Face
Despite these successes, the road to community care is often fraught with challenges. Here are some key issues:
Lack of Awareness and Confusing Eligibility: Many veterans are simply unaware of their options for community care or find the eligibility requirements unclear. This lack of knowledge leads to delays or denials, even when veterans meet the necessary criteria.
Administrative Nightmares: The referral and approval processes for community care can be complex and time-consuming. Poor communication and unclear procedures during transitions from VA to community care can also disrupt a veteran’s care.
Coordination Issues: The absence of a fully operational bi-directional health records system hinders the seamless transfer of patient records between the VA and community providers. Shockingly, some VA facilities still use fax machines to transmit critical information, causing delays and potentially impacting the quality of care.
Inconsistent Implementation: Community care implementation varies across the VA system, leading to inconsistencies in access and care.
Scheduling Delays: Veterans often face delays in scheduling appointments after receiving a referral. It can take weeks to transfer patient files to a community provider, and delays also happen when transferring records back to the VA.
Denial of Care: Some veterans have been denied access to community care, even when they meet all requirements, due to administrative issues.
Mental Health and Substance Abuse Care
Accessing mental health and substance abuse care through the Community Care Program presents unique challenges:
Limited Access to Residential Treatment: There’s a lack of timely access to residential rehabilitation treatment programs (RRTPs) for mental health and substance use disorders, and these programs are not subject to the access standards of the VA MISSION Act.
Referral Hurdles: Referrals for community care can be time-consuming, particularly for urgent mental health, substance abuse, or TBI care. This can lead to veterans not receiving the timely care they need.
Restricted Choice: Some veterans cannot choose a specific type of care, like individual counseling, if the VA believes it can offer comparable care directly.
Inadequate Provider Training: Community providers may not have sufficient training in military culture, suicide prevention, and trauma-informed care, which are crucial for addressing veterans' specific needs.
Other Barriers
Lack of Continuity: The program often authorizes a limited number of visits, making it difficult for veterans to see the same provider consistently. High turnover rates among mental health providers also disrupt care.
Billing Problems: Veterans have reported issues with billing related to community care referrals.
Pressure to Use Direct VA Care: Some VA administrators may pressure providers not to refer veterans to community care, due to budgetary concerns or a preference for in-house care.
Geographic Disparities: Rural veterans face additional challenges, including limited access to mental health and substance use disorder treatment. RRTP services are not available in every state.
Lack of Empowerment: Veterans are not always empowered to make their own decisions about their healthcare, including the option to choose when, where, how, and who they see for care. Some are not even aware of their potential choices or eligibility for community care.
Recommendations for Improvement
To improve the program and better serve veterans, several steps should be taken:
Codify Access Standards: Congress should establish clear access standards to ensure veterans have the right to choose community care.
Streamline Processes: Simplify and automate referral and approval procedures to reduce delays. This includes ensuring transparent and consistent communication between VA facilities and community providers.
Improve Record Transfers: The VHA should resolve issues with transferring patient records between the VA and community providers.
Expand Training: Community care providers who treat veterans should be required to undergo training in military culture, suicide prevention, and trauma-informed care.
Enhance Mental Health Access: Eliminate referrals for veterans seeking mental health, substance abuse, or TBI care and prioritize their admission into VA programs. Create VA certification requirements for private facilities participating in the Mental Health Residential Rehabilitation Treatment Program.
Increase Provider Availability: Work to develop and maintain a mental health workforce to meet the demand for services.
Educate Veterans: Enhance efforts to inform veterans about their options under the MISSION Act.
Empower Veterans: Allow veterans to have more control over their healthcare decisions, including when, where, how, and who they seek care from.
Allow TRICARE Select: Allow veterans with service-connected disabilities the option to use TRICARE Select instead of VA care.
Conclusion
The VA Community Care Program has the potential to be a game-changer for veterans’ healthcare. However, the significant challenges and barriers that many veterans experience must be addressed to ensure they receive timely, high-quality care that meets their individual needs, particularly for mental health and substance use disorders. By implementing the recommendations put forward by veterans and other stakeholders, the VA can improve the program’s effectiveness and better serve the veteran community. It is essential to remember that veterans have earned the right to the best possible care, and it is our collective responsibility to ensure they receive it.